What rare-earth elements are
The rare-earth elements are a group of seventeen metals comprising the fifteen lanthanides together with scandium and yttrium. Despite the name, most are not especially scarce in the Earth's crust; what makes them 'rare' is that they seldom occur in concentrated, economically workable deposits and are chemically very similar to one another, which makes separating them into pure individual elements difficult and costly. It is this separation challenge, rather than absolute abundance, that shapes the entire supply chain.
For electric motors the elements of greatest interest are neodymium, praseodymium, dysprosium and terbium. Neodymium and praseodymium form the backbone of neodymium-iron-boron (NdFeB) permanent magnets, which offer very high magnetic energy density in a compact volume. Dysprosium and terbium are added in smaller quantities to preserve magnetic strength at elevated temperatures, which is why they are prized in traction and industrial motors that run hot.
Because these 'heavy' rare earths such as dysprosium and terbium are far less abundant and more geographically restricted than the 'light' rare earths, they tend to be the most exposed to price spikes and availability shocks. A motor design that depends on them inherits that exposure directly, tying the product's cost and continuity of supply to a narrow and volatile part of the periodic table.
Why supply is concentrated
Rare-earth supply is concentrated for economic and environmental reasons rather than purely geological ones. Ores are widely distributed around the world, but the separation and refining steps are chemically intensive, generate significant waste, and require substantial capital and technical know-how. Over several decades a small number of countries built dominant capacity in these midstream steps, and it is widely reported that China now accounts for roughly 90 per cent of global rare-earth refining and separation capacity.
The concentration is most acute in the middle of the chain. Even where ore is mined elsewhere, it has often been shipped to established refineries for processing because comparable facilities do not exist at scale in many other regions. Downstream magnet alloy and magnet manufacturing show a similar pattern of concentration, so a component that looks locally assembled may still trace most of its value back to a single region.
Rebuilding capacity elsewhere is slow. New separation plants face permitting, environmental, workforce and financing hurdles, and typically take many years to reach commercial output. This structural lag is why supply concentration persists even when governments and manufacturers actively seek alternatives, and it is the underlying reason a single policy decision upstream can ripple through global markets.
Export controls and disruption
Because the chain is concentrated, it is vulnerable to policy as well as market disruption. Governments can and do use export licensing, quotas or outright restrictions on rare-earth materials and the magnets made from them as instruments of trade and industrial policy. For a manufacturer, this means that access to a critical input can change not because of a shortage in the ground but because of an administrative decision beyond its control.
The practical effects of such measures include sudden price volatility, longer and less predictable lead times, additional compliance and documentation burdens, and in some cases a requirement to obtain export licences before material or finished magnets can cross a border. Even the prospect of restrictions can prompt precautionary stockpiling and speculative buying, amplifying price swings across the market.
For anyone building products with a service life measured in decades, this introduces a strategic risk that is hard to hedge with contracts alone. A supply agreement offers little protection if the underlying material cannot legally be exported, which is why supply-chain risk around rare earths is increasingly treated as a board-level concern rather than a routine procurement matter.
| Stage | What happens | Where it's concentrated |
|---|---|---|
| Mining | Rare-earth-bearing ores are extracted and given initial physical concentration into a mixed mineral product. | Reasonably distributed across several countries, with output from multiple continents. |
| Separation / refining | The mixed concentrate is chemically separated into individual high-purity rare-earth oxides — the most technically demanding step. | Highly concentrated in a small number of countries; widely reported that China handles roughly 90 per cent of refining. |
| Magnet alloy production | Refined oxides are reduced to metals and combined into magnetic alloys such as neodymium-iron-boron. | Strongly concentrated in the same dominant region, with limited capacity elsewhere. |
| Magnet manufacturing | Alloy is formed, sintered, magnetised and finished into the permanent magnets used in motors. | Concentrated near alloy production, though some finishing capacity exists in other regions. |
How manufacturers are responding
Manufacturers exposed to rare-earth risk have pursued several parallel strategies. Some focus on securing supply through long-term contracts, diversified sourcing and strategic inventory, while others invest in recycling to recover rare earths from end-of-life magnets. Recycling is promising in principle but is still limited in scale, since collection, sorting and reprocessing infrastructure remains immature relative to the volume of magnets in circulation.
A second avenue is materials substitution and reduction: using less dysprosium and terbium through improved magnet processing, or redesigning around lower-grade magnets. These measures reduce exposure but do not remove it, because the resulting products still depend on the rare-earth chain for their core magnetic material and therefore remain sensitive to the same policy and price shocks.
A third response is to design the dependency out altogether by choosing motor technologies that do not use rare-earth magnets at all. This is the most complete form of risk elimination, and it has driven renewed engineering interest in machines built around widely available materials such as ferrite, as well as in wound-field and reluctance topologies.
The rare-earth-free alternative
Rare-earth-free motor designs avoid neodymium and dysprosium entirely, typically by using ferrite (ceramic) permanent magnets, or by using wound-field or reluctance architectures that create the magnetic field electrically rather than with high-energy magnets. Ferrite magnets are made largely from iron oxide and are abundant, inexpensive and sourced from a broad base of suppliers, which removes the single-region dependency that characterises rare-earth magnets.
The engineering trade-off is that ferrite has a lower magnetic energy product than neodymium-iron-boron, so a rare-earth-free motor must recover performance through design rather than through raw magnet strength. With careful magnetic and thermal engineering it is possible to reach high efficiency classes while keeping the bill of materials free of restricted elements, and modern design tools have narrowed the gap considerably compared with earlier generations of ferrite machines.
For a buyer, the strategic appeal is straightforward: a rare-earth-free motor carries no rare-earth supply-chain risk and no export-licence exposure tied to those materials. Cost and availability track widely traded commodities rather than a concentrated and politically sensitive niche, which can be decisive for products expected to remain in service, and in production, for many years.
Frequently asked questions
Are rare-earth elements actually rare?
Not in terms of crustal abundance — several are more common than metals like copper. The difficulty lies in finding concentrated deposits and in separating the chemically similar elements into pure form. That separation step, not scarcity in the ground, is what makes the supply chain fragile.
Which rare earths matter most for electric motors?
Neodymium and praseodymium form the bulk of high-performance NdFeB magnets, while dysprosium and terbium are added to maintain magnetic strength at high temperatures. The heavy rare earths such as dysprosium and terbium are the scarcest and most supply-constrained, so they carry the greatest risk.
Why is so much rare-earth processing concentrated in one region?
Separation and refining are chemically intensive, capital-heavy and environmentally demanding, and one region built dominant capacity over several decades. It is widely reported that China handles roughly 90 per cent of global refining. Building comparable capacity elsewhere typically takes many years.
What does an export restriction actually do to a motor manufacturer?
It can raise prices sharply, extend lead times, and in some cases require an export licence before material or magnets can be shipped across a border. Because the risk is administrative rather than physical, supply contracts alone offer limited protection.
Does a rare-earth-free motor sacrifice performance?
Ferrite magnets have a lower energy product than neodymium-iron-boron, so the design must compensate through careful magnetic and thermal engineering rather than raw magnet strength. Well-executed modern designs can reach high efficiency classes while carrying no rare-earth supply risk or export-licence exposure.
EKMO Motor Licensing
IE6 ferrite motors. Production-ready. Available for licensing now.
30+ years of ferrite motor engineering. No neodymium. No dysprosium. No export-license exposure. Power range 20–800 kW, frames 225–355+. A licensee can reach production in under 12 months.
See EKMO IE6 ferrite motors →